By Ronnie Ellis
CNHI News Service
Maybe it’s only a small fissure, but at least a small crack in all the cooperative spirit in Frankfort showed up Tuesday.
Democratic House Speaker Greg Stumbo, D-Prestonsburg, said he will discuss with House Democrats Wednesday multiple options, including an increase in cigarette taxes, to pay for recommendations to reform the employee pension system.
Republican Senate leaders immediately criticized the idea.
The Republican-controlled Senate has already passed a bill sponsored by Majority Leader Damon Thayer, R-Georgetown, which is based on recommendations of a bi-partisan task force on pension reform co-chaired by Thayer.
Thayer’s bill, Senate Bill 2, would end cost-of-living increases for pensioners, move new hires into a hybrid, cash-balance plan; and it states the legislature’s “intent” to fully fund annually required contributions to the funds.
But it does not address from where the money will come to pay for the key recommendation to fully fund the system.
That annually required contribution or ARC is estimated to be $327 million next year.
Stumbo has repeatedly said he wants “a dedicated funding source” to pay the ARC and said on Monday that failure to fund the ARC in the pension reform bill is simply continuing to delay real reform.
On Tuesday, Stumbo said he will offer multiple options to House Democrats when they meet Wednesday. He identified only one of the possible options, however: an increase in the cigarette tax, something already recommended by the governor’s Blue Ribbon Commission on Tax Reform as part of a larger re-writing of the tax code.
But that suggestion — and an article in The Courier-Journal which quoted analysts saying moving to the cash-balance plan would actually cost the system more money in the short-term — set off a couple of floor speeches by Thayer and Senate President Robert Stivers, R-Manchester, Tuesday afternoon.
The cash-balance plan applies only to new employees — it does not affect current employees or retirees who have a defined benefit plan. Under that plan, the state and the employee pay a portion of the employee’s salary and benefits are guaranteed.
Under the cash-balance plan, the state and employee continue to pay a portion of the employee’s salary, but the money is deposited into an individual account. When the employee reaches retirement age, he can take the money in a cash payout or purchase an annuity with the cash.
Opponents say placing the money in the individual accounts will cost investment returns from the system at large.
But Thayer said Tuesday that isn’t the case.
“Our actuarial analysis shows the costs under Senate Bill 2 are somewhat lower than the current plan,” Thayer said, displaying comparison charts to back his claim.
Thayer said the bill will result in less than one-tenth of one percent increase in costs to employers – really the state as each state agency makes contributions for its employees – while over time the current system would increase costs by a much larger percentage.
Thayer’s analysis indicates employers would have to pay 64.5 percent of an employee’s salary by 2013 while SB 2 would require on 40.4 percent in the same year.
“It will save the state billions,” Thayer said. He described the task force recommendations as a “carefully considered bi-partisan solution.”
Stivers, who has gone out of his way to improve the tone between the two parties since he became president in January, said the press must also play a role in improving relations, instead of “playing gotcha politics.”
Both Thayer and Stivers subsequently criticized the idea of using a cigarette tax to pay for the ARC because smoking rates are declining and so will revenue from tobacco taxes.
“You have a shrinking base which automatically means in a few years you’re going to have to have some other type of tax revision or increase in tax,” Stivers said. “So I think it’s flawed in the premise of being a way of a dedicated source.”
“It’s just not advisable to raise taxes on a declining source of revenue to pay for an increasing liability,” Thayer added.
Thayer said it’s not necessary to raise taxes to pay off the pension systems’ unfunded liabilities.
When challenged to explain how the budget – which has been cut $1.6 billion in the last five years – can produce the $327 million for pension reform without new revenue, Stivers said already projected revenue growth of 3.8 percent is sufficient to cover the ARC.
But Gov. Steve Beshear has said he doesn’t want to fund pension reform at the cost of education which has been cut at some levels or held steady at others for those five years while enrollments have grown.
An analysis of the budget by Beshear’s Executive Cabinet Secretary and former budget director Mary Lassiter last week before the legislature’s budget committees indicates the growth money Stivers and Thayer pointed to is already accounted for in increased Medicaid costs and covering one-time funds in the current budget which won’t be available next year.
RONNIE ELLIS writes for CNHI News Service and is based in Frankfort. Reach him at email@example.com. Follow CNHI News Service stories on Twitter at www.twitter.com/cnhifrankfort.
By Ronnie Ellis
- State News
Rogers: SOAR summit not the end
Its land and people fueled the industrialization of an entire country but that country has largely ignored the ravaged land and the human despair left behind.
Panel moving slowly in sexual harassment probe
A special committee of state House lawmakers who are supposed to recommend action on charges against a former colleague met again Thursday — but it met behind closed doors only to tell reporters afterward its members decided “to move forward.”
Senate Democrat to run for judge-exec in Rowan
The Democratic minority in the Kentucky state Senate might get a bit slimmer as Sen. Walter “Doc” Blevins of Morehead Thursday filed to run for Rowan County Judge/Executive.
Republicans eye House takeover in ‘14
The 2014 U.S. Senate race for the seat now held by Republican Mitch McConnell may be the most important in the nation, but it might be the second-most important election inside the state.
Kentucky Power seeks to withdraw rate increase
Kentucky Power is asking the state Public Service Commission to withdraw its June request for a base rate increase to recover costs associated with its purchase of half interest in a West Virginia power plant.
Matt Bevin makes it official
Matt Bevin, the Louisville investment manager who’s trying to lead a Republican primary insurgency to topple incumbent U.S. Senate Leader Mitch McConnell, said Friday those seeking change in the Washington must change who they vote to send there.
Request for Big Sandy Plant rehearing denied
Kentucky’s Public Service Commission has rejected the attorney general’s request for a rehearing on its earlier decision to allow Kentucky Power Company to purchase half interest in a West Virginia power plant.
Governor’s son running for attorney general in 2015
Following months of speculation as he attended political events around the state to shake hands and meet potential supporters, Andy Beshear, son of Gov. Steve Beshear, announced Thursday he will run for attorney general in 2015.
McConnell, Grimes volley over coal issues
When they aren’t arguing about the new healthcare law or where the other raises money, likely foes in next year’s U.S. Senate race, incumbent Republican Mitch McConnell and Democrat Alison Lundergan Grimes, argue over who is the biggest supporter of the coal industry.
McConnell calls Obamacare ‘monstrosity’
Republican U.S. Sen. Mitch McConnell on Tuesday called the Affordable Care Act — or Obamacare — “a monstrosity,” demanding its full repeal during a press conference he called specifically to talk about the law.
- More State News Headlines
- Rogers: SOAR summit not the end