, Corbin, KY

State News

August 22, 2013

Ky. high court considers Instant Racing challenge


By Brett Barrouquere / Associated Press

When a horse race is recorded and then bet on later via a slot machine-like device is it still a horse race? Or a type of illegal gambling?

The Kentucky Supreme Court is wrestling with that question after hearing nearly two hours of arguments Wednesday about the legality of historical racing, known as Instant Racing. The justices quizzed attorneys for the Kentucky Racing Commission, multiple race tracks and The Family Foundation of Kentucky about what constitutes a horse race and legal pari-mutuel betting.

“How can you make the determination of the validity if you don’t know what historical racing is?” Justice Bill Cunningham asked.

Instant racing allows patrons to bet on past races without knowing the names of the trainers, jockeys or horses involved. Kentucky Downs in Franklin and Ellis Park in Henderson each offer the game.

The high court case focuses on whether Instant Racing is a pari-mutuel game, like horse racing, or more like slot machine gambling, which is not allowed in Kentucky. The court is also trying to decide whether the Family Foundation, which is challenging the legality of the game, got access to all the pre-trial information to which it was entitled.

Kentucky defines pari-mutuel racing as patrons betting among themselves and not against an association, with the net wagering pool returned to the winning patrons. Kentuckians are allowed to bet on horse racing, bingo, pull-tabs and lotteries, but lawmakers have resisted opening the state to other forms of gambling.

The high court did not say when it would issue a decision.

Attorney Stan Cave, arguing on behalf of The Family Foundation, told the justices that other states, including Maryland, Oregon and Wyoming, have rejected the contention that historic racing qualifies as pari-mutuel betting.

“We all know this is a slot machine. They’re betting no one is willing to say so,” Cave said, referring to the tracks and the Kentucky Racing Commission.

Peter Ervin, an attorney for the racing commission, said the commission regulates historic racing under the same power as it does standard pari-mutuel racing at tracks such as Churchill Downs or Keeneland.

Justice Will T. Scott noted that tracks have boards visible to the public showing the odds for each race. He asked how a bettor at a historic racing machine knows the odds on the race if he doesn’t know which horses and jockeys are running and what the track conditions are.

“I’m trying to envision this type of calculation ... is this thing just rolling over like a slot machine and it piles up until somebody gets it?” Scott asked. “That’s the problem I’m having.”

Ervin said the machines list the odds from the day the race was run. Kentucky’s regulations require the approximate odds to be posted at the game terminal every 90 seconds.

“That same payout information you are used to seeing on the tote board at the track is available to this patron,” Ervin said.

The case has bounced around the court system for several years. In December 2010, Franklin Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate upheld a proposal allowing tracks to accept pari-mutuel bets on rebroadcasts of the old races.

Beshear’s administration, along with horse track executives, sought the ruling on the legality of the regulations for Instant Racing, which was adopted by the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission. The Family Foundation of Kentucky argued that Instant Racing does not meet the state’s legal definition of pari-mutuel wagering on horse races. The group also challenged how wagers are pooled, odds calculated and whether the state could collect taxes from the games.

Kentucky Downs, which will host five days of live racing, has historical-race wagering machines that take in about $18 million to $20 million in wagers per month. Ellis Park takes in about $2 million a month in historical-race wagers. It opens July 4 for a 29-day live racing meet.

Text Only
State News
  • Healthcare signup in state extended

    While the national health exchange established by the Affordable Care Act — known to some as Obamacare — suffered glitches, crashes and delays, the Kentucky-run exchange, Kynect, was often used as a national model.

    April 4, 2014

  • Kentucky budget passed with little debate

    The Kentucky General Assembly, divided between chambers along party lines, overwhelmingly passed a $20-billion, new two-year budget not only on time but with almost no debate.

    April 1, 2014

  • Lawmakers agree on snow bill

    Kentucky school officials, parents and students finally have what they’ve been asking for: A bill to allow them to get out of school before the summer fully sets in, even if they don’t make up some of the days they missed during the severe winter.

    March 31, 2014

  • Tensions rise during budget negotiations

    Tensions increased Friday between the Republican Senate and Democratic House over continuing negotiations on a new, two-year budget. It even got personal at times.

    March 31, 2014

  • Kentucky Power plan a potential landscape-changer

    Electrical ratepayers, local governments and those employed in the coal industry might have a hard time understanding the complicated transaction through which Kentucky Power Company is purchasing half the generating capacity of a coal-fired West Virginia plant.

    March 28, 2014 2 Stories

  • Senate passes budget with no locked-in gas tax hikes

    The state Senate on Tuesday passed its version of a two-year revenue measure, and unlike the House version, it does not lock in gas tax increases.

    March 26, 2014

  • House passes bill aimed at saving Big Sandy Plant

    Backers of a bill to require the Kentucky Public Service Commission to “reconsider” its previous order approving Kentucky Power’s purchase of a West Virginia generator say all they are asking “is for them to take a second look and look at all the facts.”

    March 26, 2014 1 Story

  • Judge: Companies can’t use eminent domain for pipeline project

    Franklin Circuit Judge Phillip Shepherd on Tuesday ruled that companies building a natural gas liquids pipeline across parts of Kentucky cannot invoke eminent domain to force private property owners to provide easements.

    March 26, 2014

  • Still no snow day solution from lawmakers

    Senate and House negotiators, working on a bill to give school districts flexibility in making up snow days, each accused the other of moving the goal posts – but it’s the local school districts who may be penalized.

    March 25, 2014

  • Senate sets budget with ‘wiggle room’

    It was no surprise the Republican-controlled Kentucky state Senate altered the $20 billion, two-year state budget approved by the Democratic-controlled House, but there may have been a few who were surprised by how little it was changed.

    March 25, 2014